Alone in the Dark (2024) has recently received mixed reviews from critics, with varying opinions on its storytelling, puzzles, combat, and overall performance. The Guardian’s Rick Lane criticized the game for its poor writing, buggy combat, and lack of personality. He pointed out similarities to Capcom’s Resident Evil 2 remake but noted a lack of attention to detail in Alone in the Dark. Lane described the game as “deeply tedious” and called out the performances of Jodie Comer and David Harbour as “tonally off.”
On the other hand, James Berich from Press Start Australia had a more positive view of Alone in the Dark. He found the game “uniquely charming” with interesting twists on the original formula. While Berich acknowledged issues with combat and enemy variety, he still enjoyed the overall experience and found it captivating enough to play through multiple times. Despite not eliciting fear or terror, Berich appreciated the replayability and substantial nature of the game.
Mark Delaney from GameSpot took a different approach, calling Alone in the Dark derivative and “ceaselessly unenjoyable” in its worst parts. Delaney focused on the combat mechanics, highlighting the AI’s shortcomings and describing melee combat as a “directionless flail.” While he appreciated some puzzle segments and exploration aspects, he felt that they were overshadowed by the game’s overall flaws. Delaney found the combat consistently poor and the experience reminiscent of turn-of-the-century horror games.
Vikki Blake of Eurogamer echoed criticism of Alone in the Dark’s combat system, labeling the game as “janky and unpolished.” She noted the game’s overall lack of refinement in combat, puzzles, sound, and script. While acknowledging its appeal to some players, Blake found the experience to be mediocre and forgettable, saved only by its reimagined storytelling. Despite sharing some praise for the game’s main ideas and story deviations, Blake was critical of the execution of its script and performances.
In contrast to the more critical reviews, Alexander Chatziioannou from PC Gamer praised Alone in the Dark for its atmosphere, callbacks to the original game, and compelling horror story. He appreciated the dialogue, performances, and writing, noting a sense of disconnect and strangeness that added to the game’s appeal. Chatziioannou found the game to be a success, made with intelligence and a fondness for the series. He highlighted the organic callbacks and the attention to detail that showcased the developers’ dedication to the franchise.
Alone in the Dark (2024) has received a range of reactions from critics, with praise for its unique charm and storytelling as well as criticism for its combat mechanics and lack of polish. While some reviewers found the game tedious and unenjoyable, others appreciated its atmosphere and callbacks to the original game. Ultimately, the reception of Alone in the Dark will vary depending on individual preferences and priorities in gameplay and narrative.
Leave a Reply